Riker has a history of wooing women and tackling klingons all in a single episode. When you think back to his persistance in taking Picard back from the Borg (Episode: The Best of Both Worlds part 1 and 2), he has the drive to tackle any objective that is given to him. He's physicaly strong, mentaly alert, and he has starfleets eye watching his progress, not an easy feet.
With or without a beard, Riker is the obvious choice as best captain. We're talking about a man that was bold enough to eat Klingon food and serve aboard as Klingon bird of prey. The man challenged Klag to a duelm and won! Any trekkie knows just how strong klingons are, so winning a hand-to-hand duel with them is no easy objective. Rikers prowess with a Bat'leth and phaser is uncanny. He's an excellent shuttlecraft pilot, and leads with a firm, yet caring hand. I'd follow him to hell and back. I'd follow him to the Delta Quadrent and back. I'd follow him from here to infinity, even if it meant I would never return. HAIL WILLIAM RIKER!!! It was because of Riker that I ordered a Bat'leth. (Don't ask where I got it.. Paramont would get angry.
)
Riker: 11 / 10
If I had to pick a second captain, it would be Sisko. Anyone with the balls to punch Q has my respect.
"Q: You hit me!"
Sisko nods
"Q:
Picard never hit me."
Siska has the burden of being a holy figure to the Bajorins and the captain of, no, not a starship, but a SPACE STATION! A station where fights are constant, resources are streteched, sabotages are numorous, computer errors are non-stop, and Cardassion attacks never cease. Sisko keeps a cool head while doing
all of this, and still has time for a game of baseball every now and then. Serving with a not-so co-effecient command crew of various alien species, Sisko still keeps his cool and makes things run smoothly. Let's not forget about the preasure involved with dealing with multiple dominion attacks spread over every season. Less that helpful replicator systems under the every watchful eye of Miles O'Brian. Siska has to deal with petty disputes between Odo and Quark, Bashir and Garret, Quark, and.. well.. Quark in general actual. The little troll never seems to get along with anyone. Poor little guy. Sisko, for all of these things, you have my unwavering respect.
In short... STAR TREK OWNZ!!!!!!!!