Only just saw this as it was on the random image on the front page...no wonder I missed it, I was on vacation when this was put up!
While I'm disappointed PSIV beat Earthbound, 1% is meaningless, especially since PSIV now has fallen by the wayside a bit and Earthbound is only now getting the attention it deserves (often a top download on rom sites, look at how crazy starmen.net is...) That's why it's voted lower than PSIV...it was so far ahead of its time!
(Seriously, though, they're both great RPGs and I'm glad they made that list. I've never played CT, though, can't comment on that.)